After going to seven games in the 2025 Wiffle Series, and following Guac Boys’ dramatic walk-off win in the season opener, Cheap Goats and the defending champs continued their heavyweight slugfest into week 4 of the 2026 season, with Guac Boys coming up big yet again in a back-and-forth ten inning battle, winning the most exciting game of the season 9-6. Both teams traded runs in the sixth and ninth innings before Form’s two-run homer, his fourth extra-base hit of the game, gave Guac Boys a three-run lead in the tenth, securing another victory over Cheap Goats.
Christian took the mound for Cheap Goats and retired Bohn and Alec in order in the top of the first.
Bohn started on the mound for Guac Boys and retired Joey and Kevin in the bottom half of the inning.
Tone opened the top of the second with a single, but Jan and Form were both retired to strand him.
Cheap Goats struck first in the bottom of the second. With one out, Christian went deep, and his solo homer gave Cheap Goats a 1-0 lead. Dinger was retired to end the inning.
Bohn grounded out to begin the top of the third before Alec doubled. Tone followed with an RBI single to score Alec and tie the game at 1-1. Jan grounded out to end the inning.
Guac Boys turned to Jan on the mound in the bottom of the third. Conor singled, and two batters later, Kevin launched a two-run homer, giving Cheap Goats a 3-1 lead. Courtlen flew out to end the inning.
Form grounded out to begin the top of the fourth before Bohn singled, but Alec flew out to strand him, and Christian maintained the two-run Cheap Goats’ lead.
Christian and Dinger were both retired in a quick bottom of the fourth as Jan settled in.
Guac Boys rallied in the top of the fifth. Jan hit a one-out triple, and Form drove him in with an RBI double, cutting the deficit to 3-2. Bohn followed with an RBI single to tie the game at 3-3. Alec flew out to end the inning.
Conor and Joey both flew out in a quick bottom of the fifth.
Tone opened the top of the sixth with a solo home run, giving Guac Boys their first lead of the game at 4-3. Jan grounded out before Form tripled, but Bohn grounded out to strand him, ending the inning, and Guac Boys led by a run heading into the final frame.
Cheap Goats evened things up in the bottom of the sixth, extending the game. Kevin connected for his second solo homer of the contest, tying the score at 4-4. Courtlen followed with a double, putting the winning run in scoring position, but Jan retired Christian and Dinger to strand the runner, sending the game to extra innings.
Alec singled in the top of the seventh, but Christian avoided damage, getting Tone to fly out and Jan to ground out to end the inning.

Conor and Joey were retired in order in the bottom of the seventh as Jan continued to work effectively on the mound, and the game remained tied heading into the eighth.
Form flew out and Bohn grounded out in a quick top of the eighth.
Guac Boys elected to intentionally walk Kevin to lead off the the bottom of the eighth, putting the winning run on base. The gamble paid off, as Courtlen and Christian were both retired, stranding the runner, and the game remained tied entering the ninth.
Guac Boys finally broke through in the top of the ninth. Alec singled, and two batters later, Jan hit a two-run homer, giving Guac Boys a 6-4 lead. Form followed with a triple, and Cheap Goats turned to Dinger on the mound. He retired Bohn to strand the runner, ending the inning, and Cheap Goats trailed by two runs.
Cheap Goats once again batttled back in the bottom of the ninth. Jan retired Conor, and with their backs against the wall, Dinger hit a one-out single, putting the tying run at the plate. Joey hit a two-run homer, tying the game at 6-6. Guac Boys turned to Tone on the mound. Kevin followed with a single, putting the winning run on base, but Tone escaped the jam, getting Courtlen to ground out to end the inning.
Guac Boys fired back in the top of the tenth. Tone doubled and Jan followed with an RBI double to score him, putting Guac Boys back in front 7-6. Form then launched a two-run homer, extending the lead to 9-6. Cheap Goats returned to Conor on the mound, and he retired Bohn to end the inning.
Cheap Goats’ magic ran out in the tenth. Tone closed things out quickly, as Christian and Dinger were retired in order and Guac Boys earned a 9-6 extra-inning victory.
The win moved Guac Boys to 6-2 on the season while Cheap Goats fell to 3-4.
W: Tone (2-0)
L: Dinger (1-2)
Game Notes:
Tone earned the win for Guac Boys, allowing no runs on one hit in 1.5 innings of relief.
Bohn started for Guac Boys, giving up one run on one hit in two innings.
Jan pitched 6.5 innings of relief for Guac Boys, allowing five runs on seven hits.
Dinger took the loss for Cheap Goats, giving up three runs on three hits in one inning of relief.
Christian started for Cheap Goats and gave up four runs on ten hits in eight innings. Christian became the 22nd pitcher to throw for 8 innings in a single game, and the first to do so since both he and Jon D threw 8 innings in week 1 of 2023.
Conor pitched one inning of relief, allowing two runs on four hits.
Form led Guac Boys at the plate in the big win, going 4-for-7 with a double, two triples, a home run, two runs scored, and three RBI.
Kevin led Cheap Goats in the loss, going 3-for-4 with a single, two home runs, two runs scored, three RBI and an intentional walk.